Layer 2 · In depth
What Bangladeshi analysts say
The main views of Bangladesh-focused economists, think tanks and researchers, grouped by theme - the kind of crisis, banks, trust, the growth model, politics, trade and tax - with where they agree and differ.
On this page
Much of the sharpest economic debate on Bangladesh now happens in a handful of think tanks, weekly journals and social-media posts. This page summarises it by theme, not by speaker. It attributes views to the people who hold them because the argument is the point. Where we add our own reading, it is labelled.
In one paragraph
The analysts mostly agree on the diagnosis: stagflation plus a banking crisis, with credibility as the scarce asset. They differ on emphasis: whether monetary policy should be tight (Jyoti Rahman) or whether lower rates and case-by-case rescheduling are needed from a trusted central bank (Zia Hassan); whether the main exit is domestic reform or foreign investment and social openness; and how far politics will cooperate. Almost all say that the home-made part of the slump will not fix itself, and that targets which nobody believes do damage.
Who is cited
| Voice | Role | Main outlets |
|---|---|---|
| Jyoti Rahman | Macroeconomist; executive editor of Counterpoint; chair of the Panam Institute | Counterpoint; Prothom Alo interview |
| Zia Hassan | Financial analyst and political economist; author of Unnayan Bibhrom (2023); member of the Citizens Coalition | Counterpoint; Al Jazeera |
| Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) | Think tank; its Mustafizur Rahman and Fahmida Khatun are also cited | Reports; Prothom Alo |
| Policy Research Institute (PRI), RAPID | Think tanks; PRI chair Zaidi Sattar | Reports; Daily Star |
| SANEM | Think tank; Mahtab Uddin and Selim Raihan | Surveys; reports |
| BIGD and ESID researchers | Political-economy researchers (Mirza Hassan, Selim Raihan) | Papers |
| TIB | Transparency International Bangladesh | Surveys; press releases |
| Others | Zahid Hussain (former World Bank lead economist in Dhaka); Asif Shahan (University of Dhaka); the White Paper committee chaired by Debapriya Bhattacharya | Press |
Confidence in this page: two of Zia Hassan’s Counterpoint articles were read in full by the research; his article list was read; the article on the 85 arrests could not be opened and his Facebook and YouTube output was not readable. Only the first of four pages of Jyoti Rahman’s Counterpoint profile was read. Some views come from a summary of Facebook posts whose references could not be traced.
What kind of crisis is it?
A confidence crisis, partly imported and partly home-made. The downturn comes from the Middle East energy shock and from “homegrown” banking and corporate-sector problems. Only the second is in the government’s hands, and Jyoti Rahman argues it will not fix itself; without action he expects a decade of investment-starved stagflation.1 He also says the economy was weakening before the gas shortages: growth was 2.2% in the year to March, industry was shrinking, and export and import growth had stalled.2
Candour over optimism. Pretending that growth is about to bounce back to 6.5% destroys credibility. With growth around 3-4% and inflation near 9%, wage earners face a continuous real pay cut. He wants the government to declare an economic emergency, admit the size of bank losses and practise transparent austerity.1 CPD asks for the same in its own words: a documented baseline, a realistic core budget and an integrated reform package presented to Parliament.3 Mustafizur Rahman (CPD) adds that the election was a necessary but not a sufficient condition: law and order, governance, ease of doing business and macro stability must follow.4
Stimulus will not work. The core problem is that firms cannot or will not invest, so cheaper credit and extra spending leak away until banking and corporate balance sheets are resolved.1 Mahtab Uddin (SANEM) states the loop: banks weakened by bad loans cannot finance firms; firms facing uncertain gas and electricity hesitate; weak investment suppresses jobs; job losses reduce demand.4 Mahtab Uddin and Asif Shahan add that nominal GDP expansion is not real recovery and that austerity must be planned and communicated.4
CPD’s six-month review scored 31 indicators: 12 improved and 19 worsened. It called the negative trends “entrenched and structural”, listing: no joined-up reform package, a weak fiscal framework, the external shock, “pushback from vested groups” stalling hard decisions, widespread extortion, intimidation and violence, and no step up in institutional capacity. It also flagged political appointments to universities, state firms and courts, and the abrupt removal of the central bank governor. On the positive side it noted that ruling-party MPs gave up government plots and duty-free cars, and that Parliament abolished the duty-free entitlement.3 Fahmida Khatun (CPD) asks whether Bangladesh can escape a growth trap that links slow growth, weak jobs and institutional failures.4
Stabilisation is not enough. PRI argues that stabilisation alone will not restore growth and that a new round of productivity reforms is needed (foreign investment, infrastructure) because the traditional drivers are exhausted.56
Banks and who pays
- Cost and politics. Jyoti Rahman’s cost estimate and survival view are on The banking crisis. His point is that bank reform needs revenue and revenue reform needs the banks.1
- Bank reform is a political decision. He argues that the choices (merge and nationalise, merge and sell, or liquidate) are technical, but choosing is political. He wants an independent banking reform commission with a ten-year roadmap and a working bankruptcy law.7
- Zia Hassan’s position is that the bank bill is a fiscal trap and that the least bad option was handing banks back to former owners under strict conditions;8 Parliament rejected that route. Figures and the timeline are on The banking crisis.
- The Economic White Paper (chaired by Debapriya Bhattacharya) argued that GDP growth and export statistics were inflated and that $234bn left the country; its methods are contested (What the numbers miss).
Money and trust
Zia Hassan: the value of a currency is trust. Remittances and reserves rose because the former governor was believed; a successor seen as the government’s choice loses that belief, so even correct decisions are read as favours. He reports that a banker, relayed through an economist friend, intended to advise five global banks not to raise credit lines. That is advice recounted second-hand, not a decision by those banks. The figures and the banker’s account are his own, with no primary sources in the article.9
Jyoti Rahman: the central bank must be independent, predictable and clear on the exchange-rate regime. He criticised the mid-2026 monetary policy statement for being undermined by a contradictory circular on lending spreads, and asks whether Bangladesh Bank will let the taka move over time.4 He wants tight money and a consistent crawling peg and warns that rate cuts prop up over-borrowed firms at the cost of inflation.1
Where the two economists differ
Jyoti Rahman: tight money. Zia Hassan: a balance-sheet recession in which lower rates and case-by-case rescheduling are needed, but only from a central bank people trust. They agree on what matters most: the binding constraint is credibility, and credibility is a political choice.
Energy. Jyoti Rahman: the problem is a shortage of gas and money, not of power plants. He proposes netting off payment arrears, publishing every energy contract and fixing a three-year tariff and subsidy path.2 On inflation he asks for containment without relying entirely on monetary tightening, targeted food and urban transport support, banking moved from diagnosis to resolution and “a credible employment compact for young people, not another entrepreneurship slogan”.10
The growth model
Zia Hassan argues that for 45 years Bangladesh survived on three engines laid down in the late 1970s: agriculture, low-end garments and low-skilled remittances. All three face diminishing returns: agriculture cannot absorb more workers (44.7% of labour produces about 11% of GDP), garments face post-LDC tariffs and automation, and Gulf construction remittances are exposed to regional wars and low wages. He argues that the country lacks managerial, scientific and institutional capacity and that foreign direct investment is the realistic exit, because multinational capital brings management systems and technology as well as dollars. In his October essay on 85 arrests at a private party he argues that skilled executives and engineers will not relocate to a society that polices private life, so that social liberty is an economic necessity.11 Other analysts do not give that argument the same weight, and the research found no measured growth effect (see Culture and religion). The event itself is documented: 85 people, 26 of them women, were given summary sentences without drug tests.1213 His point, as summarised, is that arbitrary state power affects who feels safe to spend, hire, invest or keep money in the country.
He also argues for an autonomous central bank, for the DP World port deal (port delays can stretch a two-day process to 25 days) and that the Awami League will not return to politics for about two decades.14 On the earlier state, he argues that removing one leader does not dismantle a patron-client operating system unless the incentives are rebuilt (unverified; no primary source located).
Politics and deals
- Growth ran on deals, and the deals have broken. Mirza Hassan and Selim Raihan explain the old “Bangladesh paradox”: since 1975 the economy ran on ordered deals; when a politician struck a deal with a business it was honoured. After 2014 the system shifted to one dominant party. Selim Raihan now describes the constraint as concentrated oligarchic power and calls for a new political settlement (History and comparisons).
- Politics may be calmer than it looks. Jyoti Rahman argues that Jamaat’s many first-time MPs want a full term to build local power, the NCP gains by waiting, and the army no longer routinely seeks power, so a full term and a peaceful handover are likely, though not assured.15 He adds that the Awami League “has long ceased to matter” as a political force.
- The median voter is centrist and pragmatic, in his view, and the challenge is to move away from patronage and build durable institutional consensus so that power changes hands peacefully.11 The strategic implications are on Strategy and deals.
- TIB warns that institutional reforms (such as the draft Police Commission Ordinance 2025) are repeatedly watered down so that the ruling party keeps control of policing and anti-corruption bodies, and that “unholy alliances” between officials and politicians block reform.1116
- Weak stake in public services. Jyoti Rahman argues that those who do not use public schools, hospitals or transport have less reason to support paying tax for them.7 That is his interpretation, not a measured fact.
Trade and tax
- PRI and RAPID: the “tax paradox” of 6.8% tax-to-GDP alongside 3.6% of GDP given away in exemptions, and “crocodile tariffs” (high para-tariffs protecting inefficient domestic firms while imposing a penalty of about 25% on non-garment exporters). Zaidi Sattar of PRI calls the NBR one of the most critical institutional stumbling blocks.114
- SANEM modelled that losing LDC preferences without trade deals would expose 81% of exports to 12-14% EU tariffs and cut exports 11.8% (14.7% for garments).11
- CPD: Bangladesh is “good at drafting commitments and bad at delivering them”; after the three-year LDC extension, public finance, logistics, energy pricing and labour compliance must be fixed immediately.11
- Zahid Hussain: political uncertainty, not only economics, froze investment, because investors knew the interim government would not last.4
What the analysts agree on
- The home-made part of the slump will not fix itself.
- Banking balance sheets must be resolved before investment returns.
- Credibility (consistent budgets, monetary policy and plans, with accountability) is the scarce asset.
- Targets should be realistic and stated plainly.
- Reform is a political, not a technical, choice.
Reading across the voices
These views are consistent with the argument that taking pays better than making for powerful groups (Root causes), but they do not all use that language. The reading is ours.
A caution about social media
Facebook also carries partisan posts that reuse the same numbers for political attacks. The substantive thread above is distinct because it cites Bangladesh Bank, IMF and World Bank data and proposes a mechanism, not a slogan.
-
Jyoti Rahman, A State of Economic Emergency, Counterpoint, 20 October 2026. ↩↩↩↩↩
-
Jyoti Rahman, The Economy Needs Credibility, Not Optimism, 16 September 2026. ↩↩
-
CPD, Six Months of the Government, 24 August 2026; CPD summary. ↩↩
-
PRI on productivity reforms, Daily Star. ↩
-
PRI, UNB: Fitch downgrade, rising bad loans expose growing stress in economy. ↩
-
Prothom Alo, interview with Jyoti Rahman: the decision to reform the banking sector is a political one, 2 August 2026. ↩↩
-
Zia Hassan, The Bank Bailout Trap, Counterpoint, May 2026. ↩
-
Zia Hassan, Why the New Governor Won’t Work, Counterpoint, 27 February 2026. ↩
-
Unverified: no primary source located. ↩
-
Prothom Alo, 85 jailed after raid. ↩
-
Dhaka Tribune, Bhatara raid: 85 jailed, but was justice served? ↩
-
Zia Hassan’s Counterpoint article list. ↩
-
Jyoti Rahman, The Politics of Synthesis 2.0, 1 June 2026. ↩
-
Financial Express, A year after July Charter signing, key reforms lie in limbo. ↩
Go deeper
- Key statisticsData & sourcesThe important figures from the research, grouped by theme in tables, each with its value, date, source and link. Where sources disagree, see the disputed-figures ledger.
- Disputed figuresData & sourcesThe ledger of figures where our sources disagree, with both values, the likely reason and how this site handles each, plus a list of known gaps.
- SourcesData & sourcesThe consolidated bibliography of every external source cited in our research, grouped by type and deduplicated, with the links as given.
Where this comes from
Synthesised from 5 research reports, checked against the sources cited above and reviewed before publication. How we work · All sources.